19/08/2022 'No Current Plans' for Scrapped V1 CryptoPunks NFTs, Says Yuga Labs

As “official” CryptoPunks owners get IP licensing rights, Yuga says there’s nothing in the works around the divisive “V1” versions.


A selection of Wrapped V1 CryptoPunks NFTs. Image: V1 Punks
A selection of Wrapped V1 CryptoPunks NFTs. Image: V1 Punks

The revival of scrapped“V1” CryptoPunks NFTsfrom Larva Labs’ originalbug-ridden 2017 rollouthas added a wrinkle to the debate over provenance, ownership, and artists’ intent in theWeb3world. And it doesn’t appear that V1NFTowners are part of new owner Yuga Labs’ increasing plans for theCryptoPunksbrand.

On Monday, Yuga Labs—whichpurchased the CryptoPunks IPfrom Larva in March—released thelong-anticipated commercial rights licensefor theEthereumNFT project, letting the owners of the 10,000 unique profile pictures turn them into all manner of derivative creations like art and products. It mirrors the approach of Yuga’s own popularBored Ape Yacht Club.

But theIP licensing agreementspecifies that it only applies to the CryptoPunks minted with the secondsmart contract(self-executing computer code that is stored on a blockchain)—in other words, the “V2” or “official” CryptoPunks that have traded for millions of dollars apiece. Owners of V1 Punks have no legal clearance from Yuga to turn their NFT avatars into commercial creations.

Asked for clarity on Yuga’s stance on V1 Punks and future plans regarding the project, a company spokesperson toldDecryptthis week, “There are no current plans for V1 Punks.”

An NFT is a blockchaintokenthat can represent ownership in an item, including artwork, collectibles, and profile pictures like CryptoPunks. The project features 10,000 total pixel avatars, and collectively they’ve generated more than $2.3 billion worth of trading volume to date while influencing countless other projects (like Yuga’s own Bored Apes).

In an interview withDecrypt,CryptoPunks Brand Lead Noah Davis—who previously oversaw NFT sales at auction house Christie’s—shared his take on the V1 Punks, referencing original Larva co-creators Matt Hall and John Watkinson. But Davis said he would “not take a definitive stance” about the NFTs.

“Personally, I think that the V1 Punks are a very cool relic of Matt and John's creative process,” said Davis. “These are evidence of how Matt and John created the CryptoPunks.”

“Whether or not they aretheCryptoPunks, I think that's been very clearly addressed by Matt and John—who are the artists and whose opinions matter, and are probably most important in this instance,” he added. “It's like a misprinted Jordan rookie card—but it's not the Jordan rookie card.”

What are V1 Punks?

Larva Labs’ stated stance on the V1 Punks was clear, but its actions muddled the message. V1 Punks really re-entered the CryptoPunks conversation late last year, when community members created a “wrapper” program that effectively rescued the abandoned avatars from Larva’s buggy, original smart contract, turning them into functional Ethereum NFTs.

Quickly, collectors began buying and sellingWrapped V1 CryptoPunks, trading them for increasing sums while calling them the “original” CryptoPunks. The V1 versions are identical to the “official” Punks NFTs, save for a new background color added via the wrapper. It clearly agitated Hall and Watkinson in the process.

Larva’s foundersclaimed that the V1 NFTswere “not official CryptoPunks” and said they “don’t like them”—but they confused the message by also wrapping and selling some of the V1 Punks that were in their ownwallets. Ultimately, Larva Labs apologized in February and donated the funds to charity, calling its actions “stupid” and a “bad decision.”

However, Larva Labs then filed a DMCA copyright claim to get the V1 Punks delisted from OpenSea. Although the V1 community was ostensibly under attack by the CryptoPunks creators, some reveled in the chaos that ensued and celebrated Larva’s missteps.

“It was a big clusterfuck, right? We really put them under a lot of pressure,” V1 Punks community member hembatoldDecryptin May. “They were just tripping over themselves.”

In March, the situation changed dramatically when Larva Labssold the CryptoPunks IP to Yuga Labs, Yuga opted not to pursue the DMCA claim, and Wrapped V1 CryptoPunks returned to OpenSea before the community launched its own Rarible-powered marketplace. The battle was over, plus Yuga apparentlyacquired more than 1,000 wrappable V1 Punksin the Larva deal, along with a Wrapped V1 NFT.

But what does that mean going forward for the V1 Punks? Yuga Labs may not be actively pushing back against the V1 community, as Larva Labs did, but holders are also not being invited to the “official” party and provided benefits as the CryptoPunks brand moves ahead.

When the V1 Punks’ ownRarible-powered marketplacelaunched in May, community members toldDecryptthat they hoped to create an independent DAO—or decentralized autonomous organization—to unite all of Larva’s Punks: V1 Punks and the official (V2) CryptoPunks alike.

Some owners held out hope that Yuga Labs’ IP licensing agreement would acknowledge the V1 Punks in some way or grant them rights. But that wasn’t the case, and the topic remainsat times contentiouson social media, with collectors prodding Davis for answers and some Punk owners (like hemba)tweeting that they don’t acceptYuga’s licensing terms.

V1 Punks owners continue asking questions, and Yuga's initial response might not be what they were looking for. At least for now, any further V1 movement—including efforts to unite the communitiesamid animosityfrom some Punks holders—will have to come from the community, as ever.

Arts

https://decrypt.co/107740/no-current-plans-for-v1-cryptopunks-nfts-yuga-labs

Interesting NFTs
The Switch
The Switch is a unique, “one of one” NFT that demonstrates the evolution of artwork in the digital realm. The Switch is developed to change form at a specific point of time in the future, known by Pak. The evolution is determined and rendered immutable by smart contracts, or self-executing code on the Ethereum blockchain.
Alex in Wonderland
A figure, Alex, stands mostly naked in the midst of a physical and psychological maelstrom. He is clad only in nostalgic 80’s era socks, on a tenuous island between active waters and a variety of shark denizens. Sharks on the right side of the image are all beached, including a shark with a quartz crystal snout, an orange shark wrapped in a life buoy, and a shark further in the distance wearing an 80’s style shirt with the number “88”. On the left side is the largest shark, wearing bright glossy red lipstick and brandishing prominent teeth with braces. She is cordoned off from the figure by a roped float divider, and within her thought bubble is a warning symbol. Behind the figure, hovering in the air, are Grey aliens emerging from the distance, out of a series of elliptical UFO shaped interdimensional membranes. The Greys take on the visual form of spermazoa ostensibly impregnating the interdimensional thresholds. As is typical, these Greys inhabit a zone just behind the unconscious topology of Alex’s dissociative mind. Though Alex’s bottom half is representative, his top half mutates into a psychological cornucopia. In a manner akin to “Auto-Erotic Sphinx”, a predecessor work, the figure has self suctioned—an act of sensual infatuation, enjoyment, and exploration. Upward exists the figure’s primary conscious eye, adorned with a revolutionary beret emblazoned with a Bitcoin badge. The figure’s summit features the nose of a fighter jet facing off against video game Bullet Bills, one of whom is marked by a communist North Korean star. A cropped section of a UFO observes the contest. Alex’s mind branches both left and right. To the left is more singular embodied consciousness, manifesting two eyes and a Ganesh trunk grasping crayons. The right branch dissociates upward diagonally, emerging into an array of eyes, faces, teeth, tail, a unicorn horn, and much more—all of which participate in expressing his unconscious being; a democracy of psychic factions representing thought impressions and associations. All illumination and darkness– fernal, infernal, high consciousness and corporeal underbelly–reside in this realm. In the distance are relatively languid, light clouds, and against the firmament hovers a colossal distant eye peering over the scene and far beyond. This painting possesses underlying genetic traits with previous works such as “Auto-Erotic Sphinx with Toys”, “Dionysus”, and “Fuku-Shiva”. The work serves also as a nod to an earlier period of art inspiration during late teens and early twenties— born out of the nakedness, vulnerability, curiosity, and wonder inherent to coming of age and all subsequent psychedelic revelation.
The River of Emeralds
Golden conditions at one of my favorite locations in the Rockies. The light, the colors, the textures; what more can you ask for? I just loved the way this river flowed into the sunset and the mountains in the background. It's rare you find a scene as perfect as this one. But when you do, you have to take advantage of it.
CryptoKitties
Hey cutie! I'm Kitty #324164. I've never told anyone this, but I once cleaned a dog. Some people say I'm the Frodo Baggins of the group. In time you'll learn how purrfect I am.
#94552
By OthersideDeployer