30/08/2024 OpenSea Gets 'Wells Notice' From SEC, Calling NFTs Sold on Platform 'Securities'

"We're shocked the SEC would make such a sweeping move against creators and artists," says CEO of OpenSea.

Non-fungible token (NFT) marketplace OpenSea received a notice from the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) that it intends to pursue an enforcement action, the company disclosed on Wednesday.

"OpenSea has received a Wells notice from the SEC threatening to sue us because they believe NFTs on our platform are securities," OpenSea's CEO Devin Finzer wrote on social media platform X.

NBA legend Shaquille O’Neal signs $11M Astrals NFT settlement
NFTs weekly sales surge 94% as crypto market continues bullish run
CNN to Sell NFTs of Its Historic News Coverage

"We're shocked the SEC would make such a sweeping move against creators and artists. But we're ready to stand up and fight," he added.

Wells notices are preliminary warnings that inform respondents of the charges the regulator is considering bringing against them. They usually lead to enforcement actions.

Finzer said his company will fight the notice and pledged $5 million to help cover legal fees for any NFT creators and developers that may also get such a notice.

"I hope the SEC will come to its senses sooner rather than later, and that they'll listen with an open mind," he added.

OpenSea is not the first crypto company to get a Wells notice from the SEC. In April, decentralized crypto exchange Uniswap recieved a Wells notice suggesting the SEC believed the company was acting as an unregistered securities broker and exchange. Similar Wells notices have been directed against crypto exchanges Coinbase and Kraken, and popular trading platform Robinhood(HOOD).

Is Art a Security?

As Finzer pointed out, however, OpenSea's reciept of a Wells notice is still a move into uncharted territory, because it implies that the SEC considers NFTs to be securities.

In 2023, the SEC brought two enforcement actions against NFT projects – Impact Theory and Stoner Cats – alleging that both projects were breaking securities laws. Both actions led to settlements with the agency.

The enforcement actions against Stoner Cats and Impact Theory, as well as a spate of class action lawsuits against other NFT companies like Dapper Labs, led to a sort of chilling effect in the NFT space as creators and companies wait to find out how they will be regulated. In July, online betting company DraftKings announced that it was shutting down its NFT business citing "recent legal developments."

In his X post, Finzer pointed to the recent lawsuit filed by two NFT artists in a Louisiana court seeking a declaratory judgment that their projects would not be considered securities.

"It would be a terrible outcome if creators stopped making digital art because of regulatory saber-rattling," Finzer wrote.

A representative for OpenSea declined to comment beyond Finzer's Wednesday blog post.

Arts

https://www.coindesk.com/policy/2024/08/28/opensea-gets-wells-notice-from-sec-calling-nfts-sold-on-platform-securities/amp/

Interesting NFTs
The Moth Catcher
In this psychologically bed-headed portrait, a creature sets in a trance; his eyes devolved and vestigal, his third eye open but hardened and in a form resembling a Sharingan. The imagery therefore expresses an awareness existing in corporeal introspection. The creature’s mind sprouts, on the left side, an emerging face, grinning. To the right side of the head, red tentacles and fingers intertwine–a collaboration of invertebrate and vertebrate consciousness cooperatively handling paint brushes of the sort used to build an oil painting. The neck and throat bristle with random thorns, as from a rose or the upper portions of a beak sprouting from its flesh. The neck itself disassociates into layers of membranous material, terminating upon an abstracted base of convoluted forms composing its body. The nose is virtually non existent, more a sinus reiterative of the shape of the third eye. Set against the exposed teeth peering out of thick, meaty cheeks, a skeleton-like impression results. That impression sets behind a visceral set of lips and tongue, which is the creature’s prime seat of awareness. Sensual, organic, the tongue organ hangs, meaty, and with consciousness of a sea cucumber. It illuminates at the tip, drawing the attraction of a nearby moth–with mystery of purpose.
#55876
By OthersideDeployer
Founder Cat #93
Good day! I'm Founder Cat #93. I've never told anyone this, but I once snuggled a dog. Sometimes I daydream of a life full of reading garfield, cereal, and watching reality tv. I hope you like kitten around as much as I do!
Stay Free (Edward Snowden, 2021)
This unique, signed work combines the entirety of a landmark court decision ruling the National Security Agency's mass surveillance violated the law, with the iconic portrait of the whistleblower by Platon (used with permission). It is the only known NFT produced by Snowden. Produced using open source software. This auction is on behalf of Freedom of the Press Foundation. https://www.aclu.org/press-releases/appeals-court-strikes-down-nsa-phone-spying-program-aclu-lawsuit
Really Remote Working Part 1
Created during the lockdown period whilst being confined to the same place every day, this piece is part of a series of imaginary places that I dreamed of being able to work from.